Analysis-Elliott, Ancora lead hedge funds in pushing for more women on boards
Written by on January 12, 2022
January 12, 2022
By Jessica DiNapoli and Svea Herbst-Bayliss
(Reuters) – Elliott Management Corp and Ancora Advisors LLC led activist hedge funds in pushing for women to join corporate boards last year, as a Wall Street old boys’ network makes strides toward diversity.
Activist investors who push for changes at companies shake up boards by putting slates of nominees to a shareholder vote or negotiating directly to add or remove directors.
While hedge funds still lag corporate America in diversity on corporate boards, some are significantly outpacing their peers in adding and nominating women directors, an analysis by data provider Insightia for Reuters shows.
Elliott, founded by billionaire Paul Singer, publicly nominated eight women to boards last year, all of whom were appointed, according to data from Insightia. The hedge fund was the only one last year to have more women than men added to boards.
In 2019, Elliott had installed eight men on boards and no women, though it nominated a woman that year at Hyundai Motor Co and had helped women get appointed in the previous years.
Ancora, run by Fred DiSanto, nominated nine women to boards last year, within close distance of the 13 men it put forward. Out of the eight directors it managed to install on boards, three were women, according to Insightia.
This is ahead of the industry average. Insightia examined the track record of 12 activist hedge funds with publicly disclosed assets of more than $500 million that pressured at least two companies in 2021. On average only about 20% of the directors installed on boards last year were women, compared to 30% female representation on boards in S&P 500 component companies, according to Insightia and a Reuters analysis.
Elliott, which oversees $48 billion, and Ancora, which oversees $9.4 billion, said they had made identifying women directors a priority, as environmental, social and corporate governance (ESG) issues gain prominence among investors whose support the hedge funds need to pressure companies.
“I have over 100 calls per year with directors. About 80% of the directors I speak with are women,” said Christine O’Brien, head of investment stewardship at Elliott.
Ancora’s co-president Jim Chadwick said that, as his firm was seeking to refresh stale boards, it found too many were “instinctively insular because they have a collection of like-minded directors, who are often mostly men.”
Board appointments by activist hedge funds Starboard Value LP, Land & Buildings Investment Management LLC and Inclusive Capital Partners LP also beat the S&P 500’s 30% level last year.
Starboard, run by Jeffrey Smith, went from four women and 14 men appointed to a board in 2019 to a 50-50 split last year of three men and three women, according to Insightia. Out of three directors Land & Buildings installed last year, one was a woman. Inclusive, founded by former ValueAct CEO Jeff Ubben, had two women appointed to boards, and three men.
A Land & Buildings spokesperson said that nearly 60% of the individuals the fund had “directly or indirectly” added to boards in the last five years were women.
Anne Sullivan, Inclusive’s chief operating officer, said “board representation is an active part of our investment strategy.”
Starboard did not respond to requests for comment.
Jana Partners LLC, the hedge fund run by billionaire Barry Rosenstein, disclosed last year it intended to nominate three women out of eight people it put forward to serve as directors.
“Jana is committed to adding diversity on boards as demonstrated by our three 13-D filings with nominee agreements in 2021, all of which included a female nominee,” said chief legal officer and partner Jennifer Fanjiang.
ICAHN’S MALE-DOMINATED SLATES
Other major activist hedge funds and investors, including Icahn Enterprises LP, did not appoint any women to boards in 2021 despite being active.
Icahn Enterprises, run by the billionaire investor Carl Icahn who has agitated for changes at companies for more than four decades, has installed only one woman on a board in the last three years, out of 19 directors he placed in total, according to Insightia.
At Southwest Gas Holdings Inc, however, Icahn put forward a 10-person slate with four women in November.
Icahn declined to comment.
Beth Stewart, chief executive of Trewstar Corporate Board Services, which helps place directors at companies and slates, said more activist hedge funds sought women as they appealed to top ESG-minded money managers, such as BlackRock Inc and State Street Global Advisors, for their support in high-stakes shareholder votes.
“I think the word has gotten out, there are a whole lot of talented women out there, so why not?” Stewart said.
(Reporting by Jessica DiNapoli in New York and Svea Herbst-Bayliss in Boston; Editing by Greg Roumeliotis and Richard Chang)